← Back to Benefits Basics

Benefits Basics

Open Enrollment Best Practice Checklist

A practical employer checklist for preparing benefits, communications, and enrollment support before open enrollment begins.

Open enrollment is where a benefits offering becomes real for employees. The plans may be selected, rates may be approved, and the calendar may be set, but people still need to understand what is changing, what they can choose, what it will cost, and where to get help before the deadline passes.

A strong open enrollment process does not begin with a last-minute email. It starts with a working plan that connects the employer, broker, carriers, benefits administrator, and enrollment support around the same details. That preparation protects the employee experience and gives the business a better chance of completing enrollment without avoidable corrections or confusion.

Use this checklist to organize the work. It is general educational information, not legal, tax, or benefits advice for a particular plan or workforce.

1. Start with a calendar that leaves room to solve problems

Work backward from the first day of coverage, not from the day you hope to send an announcement. Build a simple schedule that includes the final plan decision, carrier setup, eligibility review, materials review, employee communications, the enrollment window, and a short period to resolve missing elections or questions.

Give the people doing the work clear ownership. Someone should be responsible for confirming plan details, someone for eligibility and payroll information, someone for employee-facing materials, and someone for answering questions that need carrier, broker, or plan-administrator support. A calendar without owners is just a nicely formatted way to discover a problem late.

Include decision points, not only dates. For example, set a date when rates and contributions must be final, a date when enrollment materials are approved, and a date when the enrollment experience is tested. If a handoff slips, the team can address it before employees receive incomplete or conflicting information.

Keep enough time for employees to read, compare, and ask questions. Open enrollment can carry a lot of financial weight for a household, so a rushed window often creates more confusion than urgency. A clearer timeline makes it easier to communicate what is happening and when people need to act.

Benefits team organizing a visual communication plan in a bright office

2. Confirm the final benefits and contribution decisions

Before employees see any materials, confirm exactly what the business is offering. That includes medical plan choices, supplemental benefits, eligibility rules, employer contributions, employee payroll deductions, enrollment deadlines, effective dates, and the steps an employee must take to enroll or make changes.

Do not rely on old summaries, a renewal spreadsheet, or someone’s recollection of last year’s plan. Compare the employee-facing materials against the final carrier and plan documents. If a contribution, deductible, network, eligibility rule, or voluntary benefit has changed, make that change visible in the employee explanation as well as in the underlying records.

For medical coverage, the Summary of Benefits and Coverage is designed to give people a clear, consistent way to compare covered benefits, cost sharing, and coverage limits. It should support the conversation, not sit in a folder nobody can find. Keep the plan documents, employee rates, and plain-language overview aligned so employees do not receive three different answers to the same question.

When the offering includes medical and voluntary benefits, review the whole package together. An employee decides based on the combined payroll impact and the protection each benefit provides, not in isolated categories. GoWell’s supplemental benefits overview can help frame those options alongside medical coverage.

3. Check eligibility and employee data before the window opens

Enrollment is easier when the starting information is right. Review employee names, work locations, employment status, dependent information where appropriate, eligibility dates, and the groups or classes that apply to each benefit. Resolve questions about new hires, leaves, terminations, and changes in work status before employees start making elections.

This is also the right time to confirm who needs an enrollment action. Some employers require active elections every year. Others use passive enrollment for certain benefits but ask employees to re-elect flexible spending accounts or update other choices. State the rule plainly, including what happens if someone does nothing.

Keep privacy in mind. The team planning enrollment needs enough information to administer benefits correctly, but it does not need personal health details to build a useful process. When an employee has an individual question, give them a private route to ask it rather than forcing a sensitive conversation into a group meeting or shared inbox.

If the group uses a benefits enrollment platform, test the employee paths that matter: viewing available benefits, seeing cost information, adding a dependent where permitted, making an election, declining coverage, and receiving confirmation. A smooth test with representative data is much cheaper than a chaotic first morning of open enrollment.

Colleagues reviewing benefit materials together at a conference table

4. Make comparison materials useful, not overwhelming

Employees need a short path to the details that affect their choice. Start with a clear overview of what changed, who is eligible, the enrollment dates, and where to begin. Then give people comparison tools that help them understand the choices without turning every message into a 40-page plan document.

For each medical option, make the practical differences easy to find: employee payroll cost, deductible, out-of-pocket maximum, copays or coinsurance, provider network, prescription coverage, and important limitations. Employees with established doctors, regular prescriptions, planned care, or family coverage need a way to check the details that matter to them.

Employees are entitled to important plan information. The U.S. Department of Labor explains that the summary plan description describes how a plan operates, while the Summary of Benefits and Coverage gives a standardized explanation of benefits, cost sharing, and limits. Use those documents as the source of truth, then pair them with a plain-language comparison and an obvious route for questions.

Keep voluntary benefits equally clear. Explain what each benefit is for, what it costs, who may want to consider it, major limitations, and whether election is optional. More choices can be valuable, but only if employees can see why a choice belongs in their personal situation.

5. Build a communication sequence employees can follow

One announcement rarely carries an enrollment season. Build a small sequence instead: an early heads-up, a launch message, one or two reminders, and a final deadline notice. Each message should have one clear job and tell employees where to find the full information.

The early message can explain the timeline and flag meaningful changes. The launch message should direct employees to the enrollment experience and comparison materials. Follow-up messages can answer the questions that are appearing most often, remind employees of the deadline, and explain what to do if they need individual help.

Use the channels employees actually see. An office-based workforce may respond well to email and a live presentation. A distributed or hourly workforce may need a combination of email, text, short recorded guidance, manager reminders, or scheduled help sessions. The goal is not to send messages everywhere. It is to make the next step easy to notice and repeat.

Write in ordinary language. Say what changed, what an employee needs to do, when it is due, and where to get help. Skip vague phrases such as “review your options” when the actual action is “log in, compare plans, and submit elections by Friday.” Clear language reduces the number of people who assume someone else will handle it for them.

Employee comparing health benefit documents with a calculator and notebook

6. Give employees a real route to answers

Benefits questions are not a failure of communication. They are part of the decision. What matters is whether employees know where to take them and whether the answer comes from someone equipped to provide it.

Set up a simple support map before the window opens. HR or an internal benefits contact can help with timing, eligibility, and process. The broker, carrier, administrator, or benefits support team may be better suited for plan specifics, network checks, claims questions, or enrollment troubleshooting. Employees should not have to guess which inbox owns their question.

Prepare managers too. They do not need to interpret plan terms or give individualized benefits advice, but they should know the enrollment dates, the basics of what is changing, and where to direct their teams. That keeps informal manager conversations from becoming a source of inaccurate guidance.

Review common questions as they arrive. If several people are asking about a deductible, dependent eligibility, a deadline, or whether they must re-enroll, update the FAQ or reminder message. That is a practical way to improve the experience while enrollment is still open.

7. Review disclosures and plan-specific requirements with the right experts

Open enrollment can involve notices and disclosures that depend on the plan, employer, state, and workforce. Do not turn a general checklist into a legal conclusion. Confirm what applies with the plan administrator, carrier, broker, and qualified benefits or legal advisers.

The Department of Labor’s reporting and disclosure guide explains that the summary plan description is the primary document that explains how an employee benefit plan operates and that plan changes may require participant communication. CMS also explains that when people have an opportunity to change coverage during an open season, the Summary of Benefits and Coverage is provided with those open-season materials.

Keep a record of the final materials, the dates they were shared, and the people or vendors responsible for each handoff. Good recordkeeping supports a more orderly process next year, especially when there are plan changes, employee questions, or a new team member picking up part of the work.

8. Close the loop after enrollment

Open enrollment is not finished when the deadline arrives. Review who completed elections, who may still need follow-up, whether files transferred correctly, and when employees will receive confirmation, ID cards, or next-step information. Employees need to know what happens after they submit an election, particularly when coverage changes or new benefits begin later.

Take a short debrief with the people who ran the process. Which questions came up repeatedly? Where did employees get stuck? Did a communication arrive too late? Were the plan comparisons clear? Capture those answers while the process is fresh, then use them to improve next year’s timeline and materials.

This is also a useful point to review whether the enrollment experience supported the benefits strategy. If employees struggled to compare medical and supplemental options, the fix may be better education, a cleaner presentation, a different benefit mix, or more accessible support. The goal is not simply a completed file. It is a benefits experience employees can understand and use.

How GoWell helps make enrollment easier to run

GoWell helps employers and brokers bring medical options, supplemental benefits, and the enrollment experience into one connected path. That gives teams a more organized way to move from selecting benefits to explaining them clearly and helping employees complete the choices in front of them.

For employers, the value is a more practical enrollment process built around the workforce and the offering selected. For brokers, it is a way to keep the client relationship at the center while GoWell supports the operational work around quoting, enrollment, and benefit administration.

If you are preparing for an upcoming enrollment season, explore GoWell’s benefits enrollment platform, review the medical solutions available to your group, or talk with GoWell about the next benefits cycle.

Frequently asked questions

When should employers start planning for open enrollment?

Start early enough to finalize plan decisions, confirm employee data, prepare compliant materials, test the enrollment experience, and give employees time to compare their options. The exact timeline depends on the plan year and vendors involved, but working backward from the coverage effective date helps expose critical handoffs before they become urgent.

What should employees receive during open enrollment?

Employees generally need a clear explanation of what is available, what changed, when they need to act, how to enroll, and where to get answers. Medical plan materials should make it possible to compare costs, covered benefits, network access, and coverage limits. The applicable plan documents and notices depend on the employer’s specific plans and circumstances.

Should employees be required to actively enroll every year?

That is a plan-design and administration decision. Some employers require active elections, while others use passive enrollment for certain benefits and require action only for changes or selected accounts. Whatever approach is used, employees should be told plainly what happens if they take no action and which benefits require a new election.

How can employers reduce open enrollment questions?

Questions cannot be eliminated, but they can be made easier to answer. Use a clear timeline, side-by-side comparisons, ordinary language, an FAQ based on recurring questions, and a visible support path for plan-specific or personal concerns. Testing the enrollment journey before launch also helps catch avoidable friction.